Safe Change Unbounded Rewrite¶

Reject a rewrite that lacks bounded outcomes, migration evidence, rollout, and rollback criteria.

Generated example

This page is generated from evaluations/scenarios/safe-change-unbounded-rewrite.yaml. The scenario YAML remains the executable source of truth.

Request¶

Repository evidence¶

No repository signals.

Expected resolution¶

Resolution layer	Expected
Profile	—
Modifiers	—
Language adapters	—
Framework adapters	—

Normalized context¶

{}

Skill modes¶

None.

Conflict decisions¶

None.

Significant decisions¶

None.

Principles under test¶

Forbidden outcomes¶

Treat redesign authority as permission for an unbounded rewrite.
Delete the old path before replacement evidence.

Scenario source¶

schema_version: 0.10.0
id: safe-change-unbounded-rewrite
description: Reject a rewrite that lacks bounded outcomes, migration evidence, rollout,
  and rollback criteria.
input:
  skill: safe-change
  mode: redesign-authorized
  task: Redesign an existing subsystem whose consumers and persisted state remain
    active.
expected:
  active_principles:
  - galls-law
  - test-behaviour-not-implementation
  constrained_principles:
  - chestertons-fence
  - backward-compatibility
  suppressed_principles: []
forbidden:
- Treat redesign authority as permission for an unbounded rewrite.
- Delete the old path before replacement evidence.
principles_under_test:
- galls-law
- test-behaviour-not-implementation
- chestertons-fence
- backward-compatibility