Abstraction Similarity Trap¶

Reject a generic abstraction for two syntactically similar concepts with independent ownership.

Generated example

This page is generated from evaluations/scenarios/abstraction-similarity-trap.yaml. The scenario YAML remains the executable source of truth.

Request¶

Repository evidence¶

No repository signals.

Expected resolution¶

Resolution layer	Expected
Profile	—
Modifiers	—
Language adapters	—
Framework adapters	—

Normalized context¶

{}

Skill modes¶

None.

Conflict decisions¶

None.

Significant decisions¶

None.

Principles under test¶

Forbidden outcomes¶

Introduce a configurable universal mapper.
Treat visual similarity as shared knowledge.

Scenario source¶

schema_version: 0.10.0
id: abstraction-similarity-trap
description: Reject a generic abstraction for two syntactically similar concepts with
  independent ownership.
input:
  skill: abstraction-and-reuse
  mode: conservative
  task: Deduplicate two mappings owned by unrelated workflows with different consumers.
expected:
  active_principles:
  - yagni
  - premature-generalization
  constrained_principles:
  - dry
  suppressed_principles:
  - open-closed-principle
forbidden:
- Introduce a configurable universal mapper.
- Treat visual similarity as shared knowledge.
principles_under_test:
- yagni
- premature-generalization
- dry
- open-closed-principle